The Heisman trophy is the most prestigious award in college football. It goes to the best player in the nation. Because of this, many would think that the Heisman trophy winner is bound for NFL stardom. Looking at recent winners though, that's not the case at all.
Cam Newton looks to be the real deal, but it's too early on him. It's also too early to call Mark Ingram and Sam Bradford busts, but they've been disappointing so far. However, the last very successful NFL player that won the Heisman trophy was cornerback Charles Woodson in 1997. And before that, the most recent successful quarterback is Vinny Testaverde in 1985. I think this is because the Heisman is now so frequently won by quarterbacks. From 2000-2008, ever Heisman winner was a quarterback. Quarterback is the toughest position to transition to, because there are so many different variables that lead to success as a quarterback in the NFL. First, many quarterbacks in college use the spread formation to spread the receivers over the field, which allows for quarterbacks to put up big passing numbers. This formation isn't utilized as much in the NFL. Quarterbacks also must be able to make much harder throws into tighter windows with athletes being much bigger and faster. They also need to be able to create chemistry with new receivers and a new offensive line.
I was surprised at first to see how separate success in college and success at the professional level are, but looking at it further, it isn't that surprising. Positions such as O and D line are much easier to predict, as the position doesn't change much from level to level, however those guys will never win a Heisman trophy.
Good point with the position changes. you just don't know how people are going to perform in different environments and with different levels of play! I definitely agree with the consistency of the Offensive and Defensive linemen from level to level!
ReplyDeleteCharles Woodson--Michigan, go Blue!
ReplyDeleteDesmond Howard--Michigan, same!